You know, if the Court ends up holding that proponents of Prop. 8 lack standing to defend it in federal court, then that nullifies both the 9th Circuit's and Judge Walker's rulings, as those rulings were rendered in "cases" without valid plaintiffs.
Federal standing law doesn't necessarily affect state courts, however, so the California Supreme Court's holding that Prop. 8 had effectively
Popular Posts
-
The Williams v. Illinois plurality opinion could be subtitled "Trial Judges Never Get Confused." That's certainly an assumptio...
-
Williams v. Illinois: bad Confrontation Clause result, but not a major setback: plurality only. Alito writes for plurality. Dissenting coali...
-
Individual mandate okayed as a tax.
-
My prediction about the outcome was basically right, but I was seriously wrong about, and unfair to, Justice Kennedy. Not only would he stri...
-
Scotusblog dealing with rumors - unsubstantiated and unlikely, TBTG -- that Pres will attend Court session. That could actually raise separa...
-
The mighty Ed Whelan has noticed it too. He also takes on the question: who in fact wrote the "joint dissent"? Ed first floats th...
-
The Wall Street Journal agrees with me -- and explains, better than I did or probably could, exactly why the taxing power discovered in the ...
-
The Supreme Court has granted cert in the two closely-watch "gay rights" cases: the Prop. 8 same-sex marriage case, now called Hol...
-
Back now.I. Obamacare and RaichWhile we're watching and analyzing the Obamacare oral arguments, I'll add only this: I see no reason ...
-
Tom Goldstein (Scotusblog): "The bottom line: the entire ACA is upheld, with the exception that the federal government's power to ...